Home
Class 11
CHEMISTRY
Assertion: - 3^@ carbocations are more ...

Assertion: - ` 3^@` carbocations are more stable than `1^@` and `2^@` carbocations.
Reason :- The+I effect of alkyl groups decreases the magnitude of positive charge to the maximum possible extent in a `3^@` carbocation

A

If both Assertion and Reason are CORRECT and Reason is the CORRECT explanation of the Assertion.

B

If both Assertion and Reason are CORRECT but Reason is not the CORRECT explanation of the Assertion.

C

If Assertion is CORRECT but Reason is INCORRECT.

D

If Assertion is INCORRECT but Reason is CORRECT.

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To solve the question regarding the stability of carbocations and the assertion and reason provided, we can break it down into the following steps: ### Step 1: Understanding Carbocations Carbocations are positively charged carbon species. The stability of carbocations is influenced by the number of alkyl groups attached to the positively charged carbon. ### Step 2: Classifying Carbocations Carbocations are classified based on the number of alkyl groups: - **Primary (1°) Carbocation**: One alkyl group attached to the positively charged carbon. - **Secondary (2°) Carbocation**: Two alkyl groups attached. - **Tertiary (3°) Carbocation**: Three alkyl groups attached. ### Step 3: Analyzing Stability The stability order of carbocations is: \[ \text{3°} > \text{2°} > \text{1°} \] This means that tertiary carbocations are more stable than secondary, which are more stable than primary carbocations. ### Step 4: Inductive Effect The stability of carbocations can be explained by the +I (positive inductive) effect of alkyl groups. Alkyl groups are electron-donating and help to disperse the positive charge on the carbocation: - In a **3° carbocation**, three alkyl groups donate electron density, stabilizing the positive charge effectively. - In a **2° carbocation**, two alkyl groups provide some stabilization. - In a **1° carbocation**, only one alkyl group is present, providing minimal stabilization. ### Step 5: Evaluating the Assertion and Reason - **Assertion**: "3° carbocations are more stable than 1° and 2° carbocations." This is correct based on the stability order discussed. - **Reason**: "The +I effect of alkyl groups decreases the magnitude of positive charge to the maximum possible extent in a 3° carbocation." This is also correct and explains why the 3° carbocation is the most stable. ### Conclusion Both the assertion and reason are correct, and the reason provided is a valid explanation for the assertion. ### Final Answer - **Assertion**: True - **Reason**: True - **Explanation**: The +I effect of alkyl groups stabilizes the positive charge in carbocations, making tertiary carbocations the most stable. ---

To solve the question regarding the stability of carbocations and the assertion and reason provided, we can break it down into the following steps: ### Step 1: Understanding Carbocations Carbocations are positively charged carbon species. The stability of carbocations is influenced by the number of alkyl groups attached to the positively charged carbon. ### Step 2: Classifying Carbocations Carbocations are classified based on the number of alkyl groups: - **Primary (1°) Carbocation**: One alkyl group attached to the positively charged carbon. ...
Doubtnut Promotions Banner Mobile Dark
|

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • ORGANIC CHEMISTRY : SOME BASIC PRINCIPLES AND TECHNIQUES

    ICSE|Exercise NCERT TEXT-BOOK EXERCISES (WITH HINTS AND SOLUTIONS )|72 Videos
  • ORGANIC CHEMISTRY : SOME BASIC PRINCIPLES AND TECHNIQUES

    ICSE|Exercise FILL IN THE BLANK TYPE QUESTIONS |46 Videos
  • HYDROGEN

    ICSE|Exercise NCERT TEXT-BOOK EXERCISE (With Hints and Solutions)|53 Videos
  • REDOX REACTIONS (OXIDATION AND REDUCTION)

    ICSE|Exercise NCERT TEXT-BOOK. EXERCISES ((With Hints and Solutions)|69 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

Benzyl carbocation is more stable than ethyl carbocation. Justify.

A tertiary butyl carbocation is more stable than isopropyl carbocation. Justify.

A tertiary butyl carbocation is more stable than a secondary butyl carbocation because of which of the following ?

In which of the following carbocations, delocalisation of positive charge is possible :

Assertion : Carbocation are planar in nature. Reason : Carbocations are sp^(2) hybridised.

Assertion : Hydroquinone is more acidic than resorcinol. Reason : OH shows -I effect

What is the effect of introducing an alkyl group on the stability of carbocation?

p-methyl benzyl carbocation (I) is more stable than benzyl carbocation (II) . Heterovalent or no bond resonance.

Assertion : N, N-Diethyl ethanamine is more basic the N, N-Dimethyl methanamine. Reason : +I effect of ethyl group is more then methyl

A: on raction with HNO_(2) gives as major product. R: carbocation is more stable than carbocation.