Home
Class 10
CHEMISTRY
List any three observations which posed ...

List any three observations which posed a challenge to Mendeleev's Periodic Law.

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
### Step-by-Step Solution: 1. **Understanding Mendeleev's Periodic Law**: - Mendeleev's Periodic Law states that the properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic masses. This implies that when elements are arranged in order of increasing atomic mass, elements with similar properties appear at regular intervals. 2. **Identifying Observations that Challenge Mendeleev's Law**: - Several observations posed challenges to Mendeleev's Periodic Law. Here are three significant ones: 3. **First Observation - Position of Hydrogen**: - Hydrogen's placement in the periodic table is ambiguous. It shares properties with both alkali metals (Group 1) and halogens (Group 17). Mendeleev could not definitively place hydrogen in either group, leading to confusion about its classification. 4. **Second Observation - Position of Isotopes**: - Isotopes are variants of the same element that have the same atomic number but different atomic masses. Mendeleev's periodic table was based on atomic mass, which meant that isotopes would need to occupy different positions in the table. However, since they are the same element, this created a contradiction in Mendeleev's arrangement. 5. **Third Observation - Inconsistency in Atomic Mass Order**: - Mendeleev's periodic table did not consistently follow the order of atomic masses. In some instances, elements with higher atomic masses were placed before those with lower atomic masses to group similar elements together. This inconsistency undermined the reliability of the periodic law as it did not adhere to its own principle. ### Summary of Observations: 1. The ambiguous position of hydrogen in the periodic table. 2. The challenge posed by isotopes not fitting into Mendeleev's arrangement. 3. The inconsistency in the order of atomic masses within the table.

### Step-by-Step Solution: 1. **Understanding Mendeleev's Periodic Law**: - Mendeleev's Periodic Law states that the properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic masses. This implies that when elements are arranged in order of increasing atomic mass, elements with similar properties appear at regular intervals. 2. **Identifying Observations that Challenge Mendeleev's Law**: - Several observations posed challenges to Mendeleev's Periodic Law. Here are three significant ones: ...
Doubtnut Promotions Banner Mobile Dark
|

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • PERIODIC CLASSIFICATION OF ELEMENTS

    OSWAL PUBLICATION|Exercise BOARD CORNER (Short Answer Type Questions) |12 Videos
  • OLYMPIAD 2019 - 20

    OSWAL PUBLICATION|Exercise CHEMISTRY QUESTIONS (Is Matter Around us Pure)|1 Videos
  • SAMPLE PAPER 1

    OSWAL PUBLICATION|Exercise QUESTION BANK|9 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

(a) What was the basis of Mendeleev's Classification of elements ? (b) List two achievements of Mendeleev's periodic tables. (c) List any two observations which posed a challenge to Mendeleev's periodic law.

What physical and chemical properties of elements were used by Mendeleev in creating his periodic table? List two observations which posed a challenge to Mendeleev's periodic law.

State Mendeleev's Periodic Law.

State Mendeleev's periodic law.

State Mendeleev's periodic law.

State Mendeleevs periodic law.

Write short note on Mendeleev's periodic law.

Write short not on: Mendeleev's periodic law.

What is the basic of Mendeleev's periodic law ?

Give any two features of Mendeleev's periodic table.