Home
Class 12
PHYSICS
Assetrion: If a proton and electron are ...

Assetrion: If a proton and electron are placed in the same uniform electric field. They experience different acceleration
Reason: Electric force on a test charge is independent of its mass

A

If both assertion and Reason are true and the Reason is correct explanation of the Assertion.

B

If both assertion and reason are true but Reason is not the correct explanation of the Assertion.

C

If Assertion is true, but the Reason is false.

D

If both assertion and reason are false

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To solve the given question, we need to analyze the assertion and reason provided regarding the behavior of a proton and an electron in a uniform electric field. ### Step-by-Step Solution: 1. **Understanding the Assertion**: - The assertion states that a proton and an electron placed in the same uniform electric field experience different accelerations. - This is based on the fact that both particles have different masses and will respond differently to the same electric force. 2. **Electric Force Calculation**: - The electric force \( F \) acting on a charge \( q \) in an electric field \( E \) is given by the formula: \[ F = qE \] - For the proton (charge \( +e \)): \[ F_{proton} = eE \] - For the electron (charge \( -e \)): \[ F_{electron} = -eE \] - Both particles experience forces of equal magnitude but in opposite directions. 3. **Acceleration Calculation**: - According to Newton's second law, the acceleration \( a \) of an object is given by: \[ a = \frac{F}{m} \] - For the proton: \[ a_{proton} = \frac{F_{proton}}{m_{proton}} = \frac{eE}{m_{proton}} \] - For the electron: \[ a_{electron} = \frac{F_{electron}}{m_{electron}} = \frac{-eE}{m_{electron}} \] - Since the mass of the proton \( m_{proton} \) is much larger than the mass of the electron \( m_{electron} \), the accelerations will differ significantly. 4. **Conclusion on the Assertion**: - Since \( m_{proton} \) is much greater than \( m_{electron} \), it follows that: \[ a_{proton} < a_{electron} \] - Thus, the assertion that they experience different accelerations is **true**. 5. **Understanding the Reason**: - The reason states that the electric force on a test charge is independent of its mass. - This is true because the force depends only on the charge and the electric field, not on the mass of the charge. 6. **Linking Assertion and Reason**: - While both the assertion and reason are true, the reason does not explain why the proton and electron experience different accelerations. The difference in acceleration arises due to their different masses, not because the force is independent of mass. ### Final Conclusion: - The assertion is true, and the reason is true, but the reason is **not the correct explanation** for the assertion.

To solve the given question, we need to analyze the assertion and reason provided regarding the behavior of a proton and an electron in a uniform electric field. ### Step-by-Step Solution: 1. **Understanding the Assertion**: - The assertion states that a proton and an electron placed in the same uniform electric field experience different accelerations. - This is based on the fact that both particles have different masses and will respond differently to the same electric force. ...
Doubtnut Promotions Banner Mobile Dark
|

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • ELECTRIC CHARGE, FIELD & FLUX

    A2Z|Exercise Section D - Chapter End Test|29 Videos
  • ELECTRIC CHARGE, FIELD & FLUX

    A2Z|Exercise AIIMS Questions|26 Videos
  • DUAL NATURE OF RADIATION AND MATTER

    A2Z|Exercise Section D - Chapter End Test|30 Videos
  • ELECTRIC POTENTIAL & CAPACITANCE

    A2Z|Exercise Section D - Chapter End Test|29 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

A proton and an electron are placed in a uniform electric field.

Assertion (A) : If a proton and an electron are placed in the same uniform electric field ,they experience force of equal magnitude. Reason ® : Electric force on a test charges is independent of its mass.

Knowledge Check

  • An electron and proton are placed inside a uniform electric field.

    A
    Electric forces acting on them are equal
    B
    Acceleration of both will be equal
    C
    The magnitude of acceleration of both will be equal
    D
    The magnitude of electric force on them will be equal
  • An electric dipole is placed in a uniform electric field. It may experience

    A
    A force only
    B
    A torque only
    C
    Both force and torque
    D
    neither torque nor force
  • An electric dipole placed in a non uniform electric field may experience

    A
    only a force
    B
    only a torque
    C
    both force and torque
    D
    neither force nor torque
  • Similar Questions

    Explore conceptually related problems

    An electric dipole placed in a uniform electric field experiences, in general

    An electric dipole is placed in a uniform electric field. The dipole will experience

    An electric dipole placed in a nonuniform electric field experience

    An electric dipole placed in a non-uniform electric field experiences

    An electric dipole placed in a non-uniform electric field experience in general