Home
Class 11
PHYSICS
A, B, C and D are four different physica...

A, B, C and D are four different physical quantities having different dimensions. None of them is dimensionless. But we know that the equation `AD= C 1n(BD)` holds true. Then which of the combination is not a meaningful quantity :-

A

`A^(2)-B^(2)C^(2)`

B

`C/(BD)-(AD^(2))/C`

C

`((A-C))/D`

D

`A/B-C`

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To determine which combination of the physical quantities A, B, C, and D is not meaningful based on the equation \( AD = C \ln(BD) \), we will analyze the dimensions of each term step by step. ### Step-by-Step Solution: 1. **Understand the Equation**: We start with the equation \( AD = C \ln(BD) \). Here, \( A \), \( B \), \( C \), and \( D \) are physical quantities with different dimensions. 2. **Natural Logarithm**: The argument of the natural logarithm must be dimensionless. Therefore, \( BD \) must have dimensions that cancel out to give a dimensionless quantity. This implies: \[ [B][D] = 1 \quad \text{(dimensionless)} \] Thus, we can express the dimension of \( B \) in terms of \( D \): \[ [B] = \frac{1}{[D]} \] 3. **Dimensions of the Left Side**: The left side of the equation is \( AD \). Therefore, the dimension of \( AD \) is: \[ [A][D] \] 4. **Dimensions of the Right Side**: The right side is \( C \ln(BD) \). Since \( \ln(BD) \) is dimensionless, the dimension of the right side is simply the dimension of \( C \): \[ [C] \] 5. **Equating Dimensions**: From the equation \( AD = C \ln(BD) \), we can equate the dimensions: \[ [A][D] = [C] \] 6. **Analyzing Options**: Now we will analyze each option to see if they yield meaningful dimensions. **Option 1**: \( A^2 - B^2C^2 \) - Dimension of \( A^2 \): \( [A]^2 \) - Dimension of \( B^2C^2 \): \( \left(\frac{1}{[D]}\right)^2 [C]^2 \) - Since \( [C] = [A][D] \), substituting gives \( [C]^2 = [A]^2[D]^2 \). - Thus, \( B^2C^2 \) has dimension \( \frac{[A]^2[D]^2}{[D]^2} = [A]^2 \). - Therefore, \( A^2 - B^2C^2 \) is meaningful. **Option 2**: \( \frac{C}{BD} - \frac{AD^2}{C} \) - Dimension of \( \frac{C}{BD} = \frac{[C]}{[B][D]} = \frac{[C]}{\frac{1}{[D]}[D]} = [C] \). - Dimension of \( \frac{AD^2}{C} = \frac{[A][D^2]}{[C]} \). - Since \( [C] = [A][D] \), substituting gives \( \frac{[A][D^2]}{[A][D]} = [D] \). - The dimensions do not match, thus this option is not meaningful. **Option 3**: \( \frac{A}{C} - \frac{A}{C} \) - Both terms are \( \frac{[A]}{[C]} \), hence they are the same. - This option is meaningful. **Option 4**: \( \frac{A}{B} - C \) - Dimension of \( \frac{A}{B} = [A][D] \) (since \( [B] = \frac{1}{[D]} \)). - Dimension of \( C \) is \( [C] = [A][D] \). - Both terms are equal, hence this option is meaningful. ### Conclusion: The combination that is not meaningful is **Option 2**: \( \frac{C}{BD} - \frac{AD^2}{C} \).
Promotional Banner

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • MISCELLANEOUS

    ALLEN|Exercise Exersice -05(B)|20 Videos
  • MISCELLANEOUS

    ALLEN|Exercise Exercise-02|77 Videos
  • MISCELLANEOUS

    ALLEN|Exercise Exersice-4[B]|14 Videos
  • KINEMATICS (MOTION ALONG A STRAIGHT LINE AND MOTION IN A PLANE)

    ALLEN|Exercise BEGINNER S BOX-7|8 Videos
  • PHYSICAL WORLD, UNITS AND DIMENSIONS & ERRORS IN MEASUREMENT

    ALLEN|Exercise EXERCISE-IV|8 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

If a and b are two physical quantities having different dimensions then which of the following can denote a new physical quantity

Which of the following pairs of physical quantities have the different dimensions?

If A and B are two physical quantities having different dimensions then which of the following can denote a new physical quantity?

In which of the following pairs, the two physical quantities have different dimensions?

If P, Q and R are physical quantities having different dimensions, which of the following combinations can never be a meaningful quantity ?

If P, Q and R are physical quantities, having different dimensions, which of the following combination can never be a meaningful quantity?

If P, Q, R are physical quantities, having different dimensions, which of the following combinations can never be a meaningful quantity ?

If P,Q,R are physical quantities, having different dimensions, which of the following combinations can never be a meaningful quantity?