Home
Class 12
CHEMISTRY
PCl3 and PCl5 both exist but only PH3 ex...

`PCl_3 and PCl_5` both exist but only `PH_3` exists while `PH_5` does not exist . This is because .

A

H is less electronegative than P

B

the activation energy for the formation of `PH_5` is very high

C

`PH_5` immediately decomposes to `PH_3 and H_2` because its equilibrium constant for the decomposition is very high

D

An element is able to utilize its d-orbitals for bonding only with elements which are more electronegtaive than it .

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To understand why `PCl_3` and `PCl_5` both exist while only `PH_3` exists and `PH_5` does not, we need to analyze the hybridization and the factors influencing the stability of these compounds. ### Step-by-Step Solution: 1. **Understanding Hybridization**: - Hybridization is the mixing of atomic orbitals to form new hybrid orbitals that can form bonds. The type of hybridization depends on the number of bonds and the types of atoms involved. 2. **Hybridization of `PCl_3` and `PH_3`**: - For `PCl_3`, phosphorus has a valency of 5 and forms three bonds with chlorine. The hybridization is `sp³`, which is suitable for forming three equivalent bonds. - For `PH_3`, phosphorus also forms three bonds with hydrogen, and the hybridization is similarly `sp³`. The comparable sizes and energies of the orbitals involved (s and p orbitals) allow for effective overlap, making both `PCl_3` and `PH_3` stable. 3. **Hybridization of `PCl_5` and `PH_5`**: - For `PCl_5`, phosphorus forms five bonds with chlorine, leading to `sp³d` hybridization. The presence of chlorine, which is more electronegative than phosphorus, causes a significant d-orbital contraction due to the increased effective nuclear charge on phosphorus. This contraction allows for effective overlap and stabilizes `PCl_5`. - In contrast, for `PH_5`, if it were to exist, it would also require `sp³d` hybridization. However, hydrogen is less electronegative than phosphorus, meaning that the effective nuclear charge on phosphorus does not increase significantly. Therefore, there is no d-orbital contraction, and the d-orbitals remain larger than the s and p orbitals, making it impossible for `sp³d` hybridization to occur. 4. **Conclusion**: - The existence of `PCl_5` is facilitated by the electronegativity of chlorine, which allows for d-orbital contraction and effective hybridization. In contrast, `PH_5` cannot exist because the lack of electronegativity of hydrogen prevents d-orbital contraction, making `sp³d` hybridization impossible. ### Final Answer: `PCl_3` and `PCl_5` both exist due to effective hybridization facilitated by electronegative chlorine, while only `PH_3` exists because `PH_5` cannot stabilize its hybridization due to the lack of d-orbital contraction from hydrogen. ---
Promotional Banner

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

PCl_5 and PH_3 exist but PH_5 does not because

FeI_(3) does not exist because:

PbI_(4) does not exist because:

Solid PCl_5 exists as

PCl_5 exists but NCl_5 does not because :

Sulphur does not exist as S_2 molecule because

SF_6 exists but OF_6 does not because