Home
Class 12
CHEMISTRY
In the following questions, a statement ...

In the following questions, a statement of assertion (A) is followed by a statement of reason (R )
A : All P-Cl bond lengths are equal in `PCl_(3)` but different in `PCl_(5)`
R : Hybrid state of central atom is different in both molecules.

A

If both Assertion & Reason are true and the reason is the correct explanation of the assertion, then mark (1)

B

If both Assertion & Reason are true but the reason is not the correct explanation of the assertion, then mark (2)

C

If Assertion is true statement but Reason is false, then mark (3)

D

If both Assertion and Reason are false statements , then mark (4).

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To solve the assertion and reason question regarding the bond lengths in PCl₃ and PCl₅, we need to analyze both statements carefully. ### Step 1: Analyze the Assertion (A) The assertion states that "All P-Cl bond lengths are equal in PCl₃ but different in PCl₅." - **For PCl₃**: Phosphorus trichloride (PCl₃) has a trigonal pyramidal structure due to the presence of one lone pair on phosphorus. The hybridization of phosphorus in PCl₃ is sp³, which means that all three P-Cl bonds are formed using equivalent sp³ hybrid orbitals. Therefore, all P-Cl bond lengths in PCl₃ are indeed equal. - **For PCl₅**: Phosphorus pentachloride (PCl₅) has a trigonal bipyramidal structure. The hybridization of phosphorus in PCl₅ is sp³d. In this structure, there are two types of P-Cl bonds: axial and equatorial. The axial bonds (the bonds that are perpendicular to the equatorial plane) are longer than the equatorial bonds due to differences in the spatial arrangement and the s character of the orbitals involved. Thus, the bond lengths in PCl₅ are different. ### Conclusion for Assertion The assertion is **true** because all P-Cl bond lengths are equal in PCl₃ and different in PCl₅. ### Step 2: Analyze the Reason (R) The reason states that "The hybrid state of the central atom is different in both molecules." - In PCl₃, the hybridization is sp³, while in PCl₅, the hybridization is sp³d. This indicates that the hybridization states of the central atom (phosphorus) are indeed different in both molecules. ### Conclusion for Reason The reason is also **true** because the hybridization states of phosphorus in PCl₃ and PCl₅ are different. ### Step 3: Determine the Relationship Between Assertion and Reason Now we need to determine if the reason correctly explains the assertion. - While both statements are true, the reason provided does not directly explain why the bond lengths are equal in PCl₃ and different in PCl₅. The difference in bond lengths is due to the geometry and the nature of the hybrid orbitals involved, rather than just the hybridization state itself. ### Final Conclusion - The assertion is true. - The reason is true but does not provide the correct explanation for the assertion. ### Answer Both statements are true, but the reason is not the correct explanation for the assertion. ---
Promotional Banner

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

In the following questions, a statement of assertion (A) is followed by a statement of reason (R ) A : PCl_(5) exist but NCl_(5) does not R : Nitrogen is highly inert.

In the following questions, a statement of assertion (A) is followed by a statement of reason (R ) A: bond angle of BF_(3) and NF_(3) are different. R : Both the molecules are having different shape

In the following questions, a statement of assertion (A) is followed by a statement of reason (R ) A : Both methane and tetrachloromethane are nonpolar. R : C-Cl bond is polar bond.

In the following questions, a statement of assertion (A) is followed by a statement of reason (R ) A : Each molecule of H_(2) O forms four H-bond in the form of ice. R : ice is solid state of H_(2) O.

In the following questions, a statement of assertion (A) is followed by a statement of reason (R ) A : N_(2) is more stable than N_(2)^(+) . R : Bond order of N_(2) is 3 while N_(2)^(+) is 2.5.

In the following questions, a statement of assertion (A) is followed by a statement of reason (R ) A : N_(2) CO and CN^(-) are having same bond order. R: Isoelectronic species always have same bond order .

In the following questions , a statement of assertion (A) is followed by a statement of reason (R). A : Hybridisation of Al atom in AICI_3 (vapour) is sp_2 R: In vapour state each Al atom is directly bonded to three Cl atoms.

In the following questions, a statement of assertion (A) is followed by a statement of reason (R ) A : BeCl_(2) in vapour phase is electron deficient molecule. R : Any molecule in which central atom is having incomplete octet is known as electron deficient molecule.