Home
Class 12
PHYSICS
Do magnetic forces obey Newton's third l...

Do magnetic forces obey Newton's third law. Verify for two current elements `dvecl_1=dlhati` located at the origin and `dvecl_2=dlhatj` located at (0, R, 0). Both carry current I.

Text Solution

Verified by Experts

Given are two current elements of equal lengths dl where,
`d vecl_(1) = dl hati ` [ located at (0,0,0)]
`d vec l_(2) = dl hat j` [ located at (0,R,0)]
Both the elements carry equal current I.
The magnetic field at location (0, R, 0 ) due to current I flowing in the element `d vecl_(1)` , is given by
`d vecB = mu_(0)/(4 pi) (I dl)/R^(2) hat k`
The magnetic field is directed along `+ Z-`axis according to right hand thumb rule.
As a result of this magnetic field, there will be force exerted on the current carrying element `d vecl_(2)` located at(0, R, 0). The force acting on element `d vecl_(2)` (carrying current I) will be
`vecF_(21) = I (d vecl_(2) xx d vecB)`
` = I [dl hat j xx (mu_(0) Idl)/(4 pi R^(2))hatk]`
` rArr " " vecF_(21) = mu_(0)/(4 pi) (I^(2) dl^(2))/R^(2) hat i" " [ hat j xx hat k = hati]`
So, the force of `d vec l_(2) " due to " d vecl_(1)` will be along `+X-` axis and will have a non-zero value.
The magnetic field produced by the element `d vecl_(2)` at (0, 0, 0) will be zero as the point is lying along the length of the element.
So, there will be no force acting on element `d vecl_(1)` due to element `d vecl_(2)`.
This inequality of forces on the two current elements indicates that magnetic forces do not obey Newton.s third law.
Promotional Banner

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • MOVING CHARGES AND MAGNETISM

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise Higher Order Thinking Skills & Advanced Level|10 Videos
  • MOVING CHARGES AND MAGNETISM

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise Revision Exercises (Very Short Answer Questions )|59 Videos
  • MOVING CHARGES AND MAGNETISM

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise NCERT (Exemplar Problems ) (Very Short Answer Type Questions )|5 Videos
  • MAGNETISM AND MATTER

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise CHAPTER PRACTICE TEST FOR BOARD EXAMINATION|16 Videos
  • NUCLEI

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise CHAPTER PRACTICE TEST FOR BOARD EXAMINATION|15 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

The magnetic field dvecB due to a small current element dvecl at a distance vecr and element carrying current i is,

State the Biot-Savart's law for the magnetic field due to a current carrying element. Use this law to obtain a formula for magnetic field at the centre of a circular loop of radius R carrying a steady current I, sketch the magnetic field lines for a current loop clearly indicating the direction of the field.

Two point charges are fixed on the Xaxis , q_(1)=12.0mC is located at the origin and q_(2)=-3.0mC is located at point A, with x_(2)=8.0cm . Where should a third charge q_(3) , be placed on the X-axis so that the total, electrostatic force acting on it is zero?

Two infinitely long straight wires lie in the xy-plane along the lines x =pm R . The wire located at x =+R carries a constant current I_(1) and the wire located at x = -R carries a constant current I_(2) . A circular loop of radius R is suspended with its centre at (0,0, sqrt(3)R) and in a plane parallel to the xy-plane. This loop carries a constant current ? in the clockwise direction as seen from above the loop. The current in the wire is taken to be positive if it is in the +hat J direction. Which of the following statements regarding the magnetic field vec B is (are) true?

There are two straight conductors, carrying currents i_(1)" and " i_(2) . Both the conductors are kept parallel to each other at a separation 2d. The magnetic field is measured at a point midway between the conductors. Magnetic field intensity at the above specified point is 20 mu T when both the wiree carry current in the same direction but it becomes 80 mu T when the current in one of them is reversed. Assume i_(1) gt i_(2) and find i_(1)//i_(2) .

A current element of length 0.1 cm is placed along northsouth direction and carries a current of 5 A from south to north. Find the magnetic field due to the current element at a point located at a distance of 150 cm from it towards east.