Home
Class 11
MATHS
Determine whether the argument used to c...

Determine whether the argument used to check the validity of the following statement is correct.
p `: ` If `x^(2)` is irrational , then x is rational. The statement is true because:- Number `x^2=pi^2` is irrational therefore `x=pi` irrational.

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To determine whether the argument used to check the validity of the statement "If \( x^2 \) is irrational, then \( x \) is rational" is correct, we will analyze the statement and the argument step by step. ### Step 1: Understand the statement The statement we are analyzing is: - **Statement \( p \)**: If \( x^2 \) is irrational, then \( x \) is rational. ### Step 2: Analyze the argument The argument provided states: - If \( x^2 = \pi^2 \) (which is irrational), then \( x = \pi \) (which is also irrational). ### Step 3: Identify the logical flaw The argument attempts to prove that the statement \( p \) is true by providing a counterexample. However, it actually shows that: - If \( x^2 \) is irrational, it does not necessarily follow that \( x \) is rational. In fact, the example given shows that \( x \) can be irrational (since \( \pi \) is irrational). ### Step 4: Conclusion Since the argument shows that \( x^2 \) being irrational can lead to \( x \) being irrational, it contradicts the original statement \( p \). Therefore, the argument used to check the validity of the statement is incorrect. ### Final Answer The argument used to check the validity of the statement "If \( x^2 \) is irrational, then \( x \) is rational" is false. ---
Promotional Banner

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • MATHEMATICAL REASONING

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING|17 Videos
  • MATHEMATICAL REASONING

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise COMPETITION FILE (JEE-MAIN)|6 Videos
  • MATHEMATICAL REASONING

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise EXERCISE|19 Videos
  • MATHEMATICAL INDUCTION

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise CHAPTER TEST 4|12 Videos
  • MOCK TEST

    MODERN PUBLICATION|Exercise SECTION - D|5 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

Let f(x)=[x^(2) if x is irrational,1 if x is rational then

If f(x)={x^(2) if x is rational and 0, if x is irrational }, then

Write the negation of the following statements : The number x is not a rational number. The number x is an irrational number.

Write the truth values of the following statement 2 is a rational number and sqrt(2) is an irrational number.

If any two irrational numbers are added, then which of the following statement is true?

If f(x)={x,x is rational 1-x,x is irrational , then f(f(x)) is

If f(x)={{:(1,"x is rational"),(2,"x is irrational"):} then

Consider the following statement: sqrt(2) is an irrational number.