Home
Class 11
CHEMISTRY
Write the drawbacks in Mendeleev's perio...

Write the drawbacks in Mendeleev's periodic table that let to its modification.

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
**Step-by-Step Solution:** 1. **Introduction to Mendeleev's Periodic Table:** - Mendeleev's periodic table was developed based on the atomic mass of elements. While it was a significant advancement in the classification of elements, it had several drawbacks that necessitated modifications. 2. **Drawback 1: Position of Isotopes** - One major drawback was the placement of isotopes. Isotopes are atoms of the same element that have different atomic masses but the same atomic number. Mendeleev's table could not accommodate this because it classified elements solely based on atomic mass, leading to confusion as isotopes could not be placed separately. 3. **Drawback 2: Anomalous Pairs** - Another significant issue was the existence of anomalous pairs. For example, Mendeleev placed argon (atomic mass 39.9) before potassium (atomic mass 39.1) to align with their chemical properties, which contradicted the atomic mass arrangement. Similarly, cobalt (atomic mass 58.9) was placed before nickel (atomic mass 58.6), creating inconsistencies in the table. 4. **Drawback 3: Cause of Periodicity** - Mendeleev defined periodicity as the repetition of similar properties among elements but failed to explain the underlying reason for this periodicity. He attributed it to atomic mass without a clear scientific basis, which was a limitation of his table. 5. **Drawback 4: Position of Lanthanides and Actinides** - The placement of lanthanides and actinides was another drawback. In Mendeleev's periodic table, these series were not distinctly positioned, whereas modern periodic tables provide a separate section for these elements, reflecting their unique properties. 6. **Drawback 5: Convenience of the Periodic Table** - Lastly, the convenience of using atomic masses was a drawback. Atomic masses often include decimal values, making them harder to remember compared to whole numbers of atomic numbers. This made it less practical for students and chemists to use Mendeleev's table effectively. 7. **Conclusion:** - These drawbacks led to the development of the modern periodic table, which is based on atomic numbers rather than atomic masses, addressing the issues found in Mendeleev's original classification. ---

**Step-by-Step Solution:** 1. **Introduction to Mendeleev's Periodic Table:** - Mendeleev's periodic table was developed based on the atomic mass of elements. While it was a significant advancement in the classification of elements, it had several drawbacks that necessitated modifications. 2. **Drawback 1: Position of Isotopes** - One major drawback was the placement of isotopes. Isotopes are atoms of the same element that have different atomic masses but the same atomic number. Mendeleev's table could not accommodate this because it classified elements solely based on atomic mass, leading to confusion as isotopes could not be placed separately. ...
Promotional Banner

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • CLASSIFICATION OF ELEMENTS AND PERIODICITY IN PROPERTIES.

    NCERT EXEMPLAR ENGLISH|Exercise Assertion and Reason|3 Videos
  • CHEMICAL BONDING AND MOLECULAR STRUCTURE

    NCERT EXEMPLAR ENGLISH|Exercise Long Answer type questions|9 Videos
  • ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMISTRY

    NCERT EXEMPLAR ENGLISH|Exercise Long Answer Type|5 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

State Mendeleev.s periodic law.

What are the limitations of Mendeleev's periodic table?

Describe briefly Mendeleev's periodic table along with its merits.

Why did Mendeleev left gaps in his periodic table ?

The typical elements in periodic table are

isotopes were not included in Mendeleev's periodic table.(T/F)

(a) What was the basis of Mendeleev's Classification of elements ? (b) List two achievements of Mendeleev's periodic tables. (c) List any two observations which posed a challenge to Mendeleev's periodic law.

State, whether the following statements is True or False: In Mendeleev’s periodic table, all groups are divided into two subgroups

Which group of elements could be placed in mendeleev's periodic table without disturbing the original order ? Give reason.

Which of the following pairs of elements were found anomalous in Mendeleev's periodic table and why ? Ar and K Fe and Co Co and Ni