Both mitochondria and chloroplasts

Options

A. use a hydrogen ion (proton) gradient to produce ATP
B. obtain electron from water
C. reduce `NAD^+`, forming NADP
D. release oxygen as a by product

Answer

**Step-by-Step Solution:**

1. **Identify the Organelles**: We are comparing two organelles: mitochondria and chloroplasts. Both are essential for energy processes in cells.

2. **Common Features**:
- Both mitochondria and chloroplasts are double membrane-bound organelles.
- They contain their own ribosomes.
- Both organelles have self-replicating DNA.

3. **ATP Production**:
- Both organelles are involved in ATP production.
- Mitochondria are primarily responsible for cellular respiration, while chloroplasts are involved in photosynthesis.
- The production of ATP in both organelles occurs through a process that involves a hydrogen ion (proton) gradient.

4. **Enzyme Involvement**:
- The enzyme ATP synthetase plays a crucial role in synthesizing ATP from ADP in both organelles.
- This process utilizes the movement of protons across the membrane.

5. **Evaluate the Options**:
- **Option A**: States that both organelles use a hydrogen ion (proton) gradient to produce ATP. This is correct.
- **Option B**: Claims both obtain electrons from water. This is incorrect for mitochondria, which obtain electrons from the oxidation of food.
- **Option C**: Suggests both reduce NAD+ to form NADP. This is incorrect as mitochondria reduce NAD+ while chloroplasts reduce NADP+.
- **Option D**: States both release oxygen as a by-product. This is incorrect; mitochondria release carbon dioxide, while chloroplasts release oxygen.

6. **Conclusion**: The correct answer is **Option A**, as both mitochondria and chloroplasts use a hydrogen ion (proton) gradient to produce ATP.

---