Home
Class 12
CHEMISTRY
Assertion (A) : Pb^(+4) compounds are s...

Assertion (A) :` Pb^(+4)` compounds are stronger oxidiising agents than ` Sn^(4+)` compounds .
Reason (R): The higher oxidation states for group `14` elements are more stable for the heavier members of the group due to inert pair effect .

A

Statement-1 is Ture, Statement-2 is True, Statement-2 is a correct explanation for Statement-1.

B

Statement-1 is True, Statement-2 is Ture, Statement-2 is NOT a correct explanation for Statement-1

C

Statement-1 is Ture, Statement-2 is False

D

Statement-1 is Flase, Statement-2 is True

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To solve the assertion and reason question, we will analyze both the assertion (A) and the reason (R) step by step. ### Step 1: Analyze the Assertion (A) The assertion states that Pb^(4+) compounds are stronger oxidizing agents than Sn^(4+) compounds. - **Understanding Oxidizing Agents**: An oxidizing agent is a substance that can accept electrons and is reduced in the process. The strength of an oxidizing agent is often related to the stability of its higher oxidation state. - **Lead (Pb) vs. Tin (Sn)**: Lead in the +4 oxidation state (Pb^(4+)) is less stable compared to its +2 oxidation state (Pb^(2+)). This instability makes Pb^(4+) a stronger oxidizing agent because it tends to be reduced to Pb^(2+). - **Tin (Sn)**: On the other hand, Sn^(4+) is relatively more stable than Sn^(2+). This means that Sn^(4+) is less likely to act as an oxidizing agent compared to Pb^(4+). **Conclusion for Assertion**: The assertion is correct; Pb^(4+) compounds are indeed stronger oxidizing agents than Sn^(4+) compounds. ### Step 2: Analyze the Reason (R) The reason states that the higher oxidation states for group 14 elements are more stable for the heavier members of the group due to the inert pair effect. - **Inert Pair Effect**: The inert pair effect refers to the tendency of the outermost s-electrons to remain non-bonding in heavier elements of a group. As we move down group 14 from carbon to lead, the +2 oxidation state becomes more stable compared to the +4 oxidation state due to this effect. - **Application to Pb and Sn**: For heavier elements like lead, the +2 oxidation state is favored, making the +4 state less stable. Conversely, for tin, the +4 state is relatively more stable compared to lead's +4 state. **Conclusion for Reason**: The reason is incorrect; higher oxidation states are not more stable for heavier members due to the inert pair effect. In fact, the +2 state is more stable for heavier elements. ### Final Conclusion - **Assertion (A)**: True - **Reason (R)**: False ### Summary The assertion is correct while the reason is incorrect. Therefore, the statement "Pb^(4+) compounds are stronger oxidizing agents than Sn^(4+) compounds" is true, but the reasoning provided does not support this assertion. ---

To solve the assertion and reason question, we will analyze both the assertion (A) and the reason (R) step by step. ### Step 1: Analyze the Assertion (A) The assertion states that Pb^(4+) compounds are stronger oxidizing agents than Sn^(4+) compounds. - **Understanding Oxidizing Agents**: An oxidizing agent is a substance that can accept electrons and is reduced in the process. The strength of an oxidizing agent is often related to the stability of its higher oxidation state. - **Lead (Pb) vs. Tin (Sn)**: Lead in the +4 oxidation state (Pb^(4+)) is less stable compared to its +2 oxidation state (Pb^(2+)). This instability makes Pb^(4+) a stronger oxidizing agent because it tends to be reduced to Pb^(2+). - **Tin (Sn)**: On the other hand, Sn^(4+) is relatively more stable than Sn^(2+). This means that Sn^(4+) is less likely to act as an oxidizing agent compared to Pb^(4+). ...
Doubtnut Promotions Banner Mobile Dark
|

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • PERIODIC TABLE & PERIODICITY

    RESONANCE ENGLISH|Exercise Exercise-2|1 Videos
  • PERIODIC TABLE & PERIODICITY

    RESONANCE ENGLISH|Exercise Exercise-3|1 Videos
  • PERIODIC TABLE & PERIODICITY

    RESONANCE ENGLISH|Exercise Exercise-1|1 Videos
  • P-BLOCK ELEMENTS (HALOGEN & NOBLE GASES)

    RESONANCE ENGLISH|Exercise APSP PART-3|22 Videos
  • QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS

    RESONANCE ENGLISH|Exercise INORGANIC CHMISTRY(Qualitative analysis)|35 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

Assertion (A) : PbI_4 is a stable compound . Reason (R) : Iodide ion stablised by higher oxidation state

Assertion (A): KMnO_(4) is a stronger oxidising agent than K_(2)Cr_(2)O_(7) . Reason (R ): This is due to increasing stability of the lower species to which they are reduced.

Knowledge Check

  • Assertion : Cr(VI) in the form of dichromate in acidic medium is a strong oxidising agent where MoO_3 and WO_3 are not. Reason: In d-block elements higher oxidation states are favoured by heavier members.

    A
    If both assertion and reason are true and reason is the correct explanation of assertion.
    B
    If both assertion and reason are true and reason not is the correct explanation of assertion.
    C
    If assertion is trun but reason is false.
    D
    If both assertion and reason are false.
  • Assertion: - 3^@ carbocations are more stable than 1^@ and 2^@ carbocations. Reason :- The+I effect of alkyl groups decreases the magnitude of positive charge to the maximum possible extent in a 3^@ carbocation

    A
    If both Assertion and Reason are CORRECT and Reason is the CORRECT explanation of the Assertion.
    B
    If both Assertion and Reason are CORRECT but Reason is not the CORRECT explanation of the Assertion.
    C
    If Assertion is CORRECT but Reason is INCORRECT.
    D
    If Assertion is INCORRECT but Reason is CORRECT.
  • Similar Questions

    Explore conceptually related problems

    Ni (II) compounds are thermodynamically more stable than Pt(II) compounds but the order is reverse in case of + 4 oxidation states. Why?

    Assertion :- Oxidation number of Carbon in all it's compounds is +4 . Reason :- An element has a fixed oxidation state.

    What are the common oxidation states exhibited by the elements of group 14 and which state is more stable for Pb ?

    Assertion :- Oxidation number of S in HSO_(3)^(-) is +4 . Reason :- Sulphur is in different oxidation state in different compounds.

    Assertion : PbI_(4) doesn't exist and converts into PbI_(2) and I_(2) spontaneously at room temperature but PbCl_(4) needs heatin to convert into PbCl_(2) and Cl_(2) . Reason : Pb^(2+) is more stable than Pb^(4+) due to inert pair effect.

    Assertion : PbI_(4) doesn't exist and converts into PbI_(2) and I_(2) spontaneously at room temperature but PbCl_(4) needs heatin to convert into PbCl_(2) and Cl_(2) . Reason : Pb^(2+) is more stable than Pb^(4+) due to inert pair effect.