Plants cannot be grown in

Options

A. Soil with essential minerals
B. Water with essential minerals
C. Either soil or water with essential minerals
D. Water or soil without essential minerals

Answer

**Step-by-Step Solution:**

1. **Understanding the Question**: The question asks in which condition plants cannot be grown. This implies we need to identify the importance of essential minerals for plant growth.

2. **Defining Essential Elements**: Essential elements are the minerals and nutrients that plants require for their growth and reproduction. These include macronutrients (like nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium) and micronutrients (like iron, manganese, zinc).

3. **Analyzing the Options**:
- **Option 1**: Soil with essential minerals - Plants can grow here since essential minerals are present.
- **Option 2**: Water with essential minerals - Plants can also grow here as essential minerals are available.
- **Option 3**: Either soil or water with essential minerals - Again, plants can grow in this scenario due to the presence of essential minerals.
- **Option 4**: Water or soil without essential minerals - This is the critical option, as the absence of essential minerals means plants cannot grow.

4. **Conclusion**: Based on the analysis of the options, the correct answer is **Option 4: Water or soil without essential minerals**. Without these essential nutrients, plants cannot sustain their growth or reproduction.

---