Home
Class 12
MATHS
Suppose p,q,r are positive rational numb...

Suppose p,q,r are positive rational numbers such that `sqrtp+sqrtq+sqrtr` are irrational. Then

A

`sqrtp, sqrtq,sqrtr` are irrational

B

`sqrt(pq)sqrt(pr),sqrt(qr)` are rational, but `sqrtp,sqrtq,sqrtr` are irrational

C

`sqrtp,sqrtq,sqrtr` are rational

D

`sqrt(pq)sqrt(pr)sqrt(qr)` are irrational

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To solve the problem, we need to analyze the conditions given and derive the conclusion step by step. ### Step 1: Understand the Given Information We are given that \( p, q, r \) are positive rational numbers and that \( \sqrt{p} + \sqrt{q} + \sqrt{r} \) is irrational. ### Step 2: Analyze the Implications Since \( p, q, r \) are rational, their square roots \( \sqrt{p}, \sqrt{q}, \sqrt{r} \) can either be rational or irrational. However, the sum of three rational numbers is always rational. Therefore, at least one of \( \sqrt{p}, \sqrt{q}, \sqrt{r} \) must be irrational for the sum to be irrational. ### Step 3: Case Analysis We will analyze three cases based on how many of \( \sqrt{p}, \sqrt{q}, \sqrt{r} \) are irrational. #### Case 1: Exactly One of \( \sqrt{p}, \sqrt{q}, \sqrt{r} \) is Irrational Assume \( \sqrt{p} \) is irrational and \( \sqrt{q}, \sqrt{r} \) are rational. Then: \[ \sqrt{p} + \sqrt{q} + \sqrt{r} = \text{(irrational)} + \text{(rational)} + \text{(rational)} = \text{irrational} \] This case holds true. #### Case 2: Exactly Two of \( \sqrt{p}, \sqrt{q}, \sqrt{r} \) are Irrational Assume \( \sqrt{p} \) and \( \sqrt{q} \) are irrational, and \( \sqrt{r} \) is rational. Then: \[ \sqrt{p} + \sqrt{q} + \sqrt{r} = \text{(irrational)} + \text{(irrational)} + \text{(rational)} = \text{irrational} \] This case also holds true. #### Case 3: All Three \( \sqrt{p}, \sqrt{q}, \sqrt{r} \) are Irrational If all three are irrational, then: \[ \sqrt{p} + \sqrt{q} + \sqrt{r} = \text{(irrational)} + \text{(irrational)} + \text{(irrational)} = \text{irrational} \] This case also holds true. ### Step 4: Conclusion From the analysis, we see that the sum \( \sqrt{p} + \sqrt{q} + \sqrt{r} \) can be irrational in all three cases. However, if we consider the implications of rationality and irrationality, we conclude that: - If all three square roots were irrational, their sum would not necessarily be irrational unless they are specifically chosen to be conjugates. Thus, the only consistent conclusion is that at least one of the square roots must be rational, leading to the conclusion that at least one of \( \sqrt{p}, \sqrt{q}, \sqrt{r} \) must be rational. ### Final Answer The correct statement is that at least one of \( \sqrt{p}, \sqrt{q}, \sqrt{r} \) must be rational. ---
Promotional Banner

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • QUESTION PAPER 2020

    KVPY PREVIOUS YEAR|Exercise PART-II : MATHEMATICS|7 Videos
  • QUESTION PAPER 2020

    KVPY PREVIOUS YEAR|Exercise PART-I (MATHEMATICS)|20 Videos
  • QUESTION PAPER 2013

    KVPY PREVIOUS YEAR|Exercise PART-II ( MATHEMATICS)|10 Videos
  • SOLVED PAPER 2018

    KVPY PREVIOUS YEAR|Exercise EXAMPLE|27 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

Suppose p, q, r are positive rational numbers such that sqrtp + sqrtq + sqrtr is also rational. Then

If p,q are prime positive integers,prove that sqrt(p)+sqrt(q) is an irrational number.

Is pi a rational or an irrational numbers?

If Q is the set of rational numbers and P is the set of irrational numbers, then

If p and r are positive real numbers,then the quantity (p+r)/(q+r) is

All the rational numbers are irrational also.

Assertion : sqrt2 is an irrational number. Reason : If p be a prime, then sqrtp is an irrational number.