Use the statement given below to answer the questions that follow.in
All good athletes want to win and all athletes who want to win, eat a well-balanced diet, therefore, all athletes who do not eat a well-balanced diet are bad athletes.
Which of the following, if true, would refute the assumptions of the arguments above ?

Options

A. Bob, the accountant, eats a well-balanced diet, but he is not a good athlete.
B. Ana wants to win, but she is not a good athlete.
C. All the players on the Burros baseball team eata well balanced diet.
D. Cindy, the basketball star, does not eat a well balanced diet, but she is a good athelete.

Answer

D

Explanation

The statement .Cindy, the basketball star, does not eat a well-balanced diet, but she is a good athelete. contradicts the hidden assumptions of the above argument.