Home
Class 12
BIOLOGY
Assertion : Miller used four gases-metha...

Assertion : Miller used four gases-methane, oxygen, hydrogen and water vapour for formation of simple organic compounds.
Reason : He prepared some amino acids in his apparatus.

A

If both the assertion and the reason are true and the reason is a correct explanation of the assertion

B

If both the assertion and reason are true but the reason is not a correct explanation of the assertion

C

If the assertion is true but the reason is false

D

If the assertion is false but reason is true

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
**Step-by-Step Solution:** 1. **Understanding the Assertion**: The assertion states that Miller used four gases: methane, oxygen, hydrogen, and water vapor for the formation of simple organic compounds. 2. **Evaluating the Gases Used**: In reality, Miller did not use oxygen in his experiment. The gases he used were methane (CH₄), ammonia (NH₃), hydrogen (H₂), and water vapor (H₂O). Oxygen was not present in the early Earth's atmosphere, as it would react with other components and not remain free. 3. **Understanding the Reason**: The reason states that Miller prepared some amino acids in his apparatus. This is true as Miller's experiment did lead to the formation of amino acids, which are the building blocks of proteins. 4. **Conclusion on Assertion and Reason**: Since the assertion is incorrect (as it includes oxygen which was not part of the early atmosphere), but the reason is correct (Miller did produce amino acids), we can conclude that the assertion is false while the reason is true. 5. **Final Answer**: Therefore, the correct answer is that the assertion is false, but the reason is true.

**Step-by-Step Solution:** 1. **Understanding the Assertion**: The assertion states that Miller used four gases: methane, oxygen, hydrogen, and water vapor for the formation of simple organic compounds. 2. **Evaluating the Gases Used**: In reality, Miller did not use oxygen in his experiment. The gases he used were methane (CH₄), ammonia (NH₃), hydrogen (H₂), and water vapor (H₂O). Oxygen was not present in the early Earth's atmosphere, as it would react with other components and not remain free. 3. **Understanding the Reason**: The reason states that Miller prepared some amino acids in his apparatus. This is true as Miller's experiment did lead to the formation of amino acids, which are the building blocks of proteins. ...
Promotional Banner

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

Assertion : Sodium extract is prepared for identification of elements in organic compounds. Reason : Organic compounds on fusiono with sodium gives ionic compounds, soluble in water.

Assertion: Amount of biodegradable organic matter present in water is measured by BOD of water Reason: During biodegradation of organic compounds. Oxygen is released

Assertion : In the formation of water octet molecule, both hydrogen and oxygen atoms attain octet of electrons. Reason : Oxygen atom forms two ionic or electrovalent bonds with two hydrogen atoms.

Assertion : Amino acids are called alpha -amino acids. Reason : Amino acids are organic compounds containing an amino group and an acidic group as substituents on the alpha -carbon.

(a) State the hypothesis which S.L. Miller tried to prove in the laboratory with the help of the set up given above. (b) Name the organic compound observed by him in the liquid water at the end of his experiment. (c) A scientist simulated a similar set up and added CH_(4), CH_(3) and water vapour at 800^(@)C Mention the important component that is missing in his experiment ?

Assertion : Amino acid are called alpha -amino acids Reason : Amino acid are organic compound containing an amino goup and a carboxyl group as substituents on the same carbon, i.e., the alpha -carbon.