Home
Class 12
PHYSICS
Mention any one demerit of Huygens' wave...

Mention any one demerit of Huygens' wave theory of light.

Text Solution

Verified by Experts

Huygens' wave theory of light (1678) :
(1) Light emitted by a source propagates in the form of waves. Huygens' original theory assumed them to be longitudinal waves.
In a hormogeneous isotropic medium, light from a point source spreads by spherical waves.
It was thought that a wave motion needed a medium for its propagation. Hence, the theory postulated a medium called luminiferous ether that exists everywhere, in vacuum as well as in transparent bodies. Ether had to be assigned some extraordinary properties,a high modulus of elasticity to account for the high speed of light, zero density so that it offers no resistance to planetary, and perfect transparency.
(4) The different colours of light due to the different wavelengths.
Merits of the theory :
(1) Huygens' wave theory satisfactorily explains reflection and refrection as well as their simultanneity.
(2) In explaining refraction, the theory concludes that the speed of light in a denser medium is less than that in a rarer medium, which agreed with later experimental findings.
(3) The theory was later used by Young (1800-04), Fraunhoffer and Fresnel (1814) to satisfactorily explain interference, diffraction and rectiolinear propagation of light. The phenomenon of polarisation could also be explained considering the light waves to be transverse.
Demerits of the theory :
(1) It was found much later that the hypothetical medium, luminiferous ether, has no experimental basis. In 1905, Einstein discarden the idea of ether completely.
(2) Phenomena like absorption and emission of light by atoms and molecules, photoelectric effect, Raman effect, Compton effect, etc., cannot be explained on the basis of the wave theory.
Promotional Banner

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • LAWS AND THEORIES

    NAVNEET PUBLICATION - MAHARASHTRA BOARD|Exercise Current Electricity|1 Videos
  • LAWS AND THEORIES

    NAVNEET PUBLICATION - MAHARASHTRA BOARD|Exercise Magnetic Effect of Electric Current|1 Videos
  • LAWS AND THEORIES

    NAVNEET PUBLICATION - MAHARASHTRA BOARD|Exercise Stationary Waves|1 Videos
  • INSTRUMENTS : CONSTRUCTION AND WORKING

    NAVNEET PUBLICATION - MAHARASHTRA BOARD|Exercise Semiconductors|6 Videos
  • MODEL QUESTION PAPER

    NAVNEET PUBLICATION - MAHARASHTRA BOARD|Exercise SECTION- D|5 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

Huygens wave theory is used

Huygens's wave theory could explain

There are many scientific models proposed and failed . The orpuscular theory is an example of such case . The corpuscular theory given by Newton was later replaced by Huygen's wave theory of light . This was further replaced by Plank's quantum theory and finally by De-Broglie's hypothesis . Comment on the fact that despite failures in the above in the above theories, we stress on the study of all the above given theories .

Huygens wave theory allows us to know

State the postulates of Huygens' wave theory.