Home
Class 11
CHEMISTRY
Assertionj: The following structures (I)...

Assertionj: The following structures (I) and (II) canot e the major contributors to the real structure of `CH_(3)COOCH_(3)`
`CH_(3)-underset(I)underset(+)overset( : overset(..)(C)^(-): )overset(|)(C)-underset(..)overset(..)(O)harrunderset(II)(CH_(3)-overset( : overset(..)(O)^(-): )overset(|)(C)=underset(..)overset(+)(O)-CH_(3))`
Reason: Both the structures involve charge separation and structure (I) contains a carbon atom with an incomplete octet.

A

If both assertion and reason are true and reason is the correct explanation of assertion

B

If both assertion and reason are true but reason is not the correct explanation of assertion

C

If assertion is true but reason is false.

D

If both assertion and reason are false.

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To solve the question, we will analyze both the assertion and the reason provided, and determine their validity in the context of the structures of methyl acetate (CH₃COOCH₃). ### Step 1: Understanding the Structures The question presents two structures (I) and (II) as potential resonance contributors for methyl acetate. We need to analyze these structures to see if they can be major contributors. **Structure I:** - This structure has a positive charge on a carbon atom and a negative charge on an adjacent carbon atom. - A carbon atom with a positive charge typically has an incomplete octet, which makes it less stable. **Structure II:** - This structure has a positive charge on the oxygen atom and a negative charge on the adjacent carbon atom. - While oxygen can accommodate a positive charge, it is electronegative and prefers to hold onto its electrons. ### Step 2: Evaluating the Assertion The assertion states that structures I and II cannot be the major contributors to the real structure of methyl acetate. - **Analysis:** - Structure I has a carbon with an incomplete octet, which is not favorable. - Structure II has charge separation, which also destabilizes the molecule. Thus, the assertion is **correct** because both structures are not favorable contributors due to charge separation and the incomplete octet in structure I. ### Step 3: Evaluating the Reason The reason states that both structures involve charge separation and that structure I contains a carbon atom with an incomplete octet. - **Analysis:** - Both structures indeed involve charge separation. - Structure I does have a carbon atom with an incomplete octet, which makes it less stable. Therefore, the reason is also **correct** and it correctly explains why the assertion is true. ### Step 4: Conclusion Since both the assertion and reason are correct, and the reason explains the assertion, we conclude that: - **Assertion:** True - **Reason:** True and explains the assertion. Thus, the answer to the question is that both statements are correct, but the assertion stands alone as the primary conclusion. ### Final Answer: **Assertion is correct, Reason is correct and explains the Assertion.** ---
Promotional Banner

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • ORGANIC CHEMISTRY-SOME BASIC PRINCIPLES AND TECHNIQUES

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Tetravalence Of Carbon : Shape Of Organic Compounds|5 Videos
  • ORGANIC CHEMISTRY-SOME BASIC PRINCIPLES AND TECHNIQUES

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Nomenclature Of Organic Compounds|12 Videos
  • ORGANIC CHEMISTRY-SOME BASIC PRINCIPLES AND TECHNIQUES

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Exemplar Problems|12 Videos
  • HYDROGEN

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Assertion And Reason|15 Videos
  • PRACTICE PAPER 1

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Practice Paper 1|44 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

CH_(3)-underset(CH_(3))underset(|)overset(CH_(3))overset(|)C-CH=CH-CH_(3)overset(H-Cl)(to) ?

The correct order of reactivity of PhMgBr with underset((I))(Ph-underset(C)overset(O)overset(||)(C)-Ph)" " underset((II))(CH_(3)-overset(O)overset(||)(C)-H)" " underset((III))(CH_(3)-overset(O)overset(||)(C)-CH_(3)) is

The correct order of reactivity of PhMgBr with underset((I))(Ph-underset(C)overset(O)overset(||)(C)-Ph)" " underset((II))(CH_(3)-overset(O)overset(||)(C)-H)" " underset((III))(CH_(3)-overset(O)overset(||)(C)-CH_(3)) is

CH_(3)-underset(CH_3)underset(|)overset(CH_3)overset(|)(C )-underset(Br)underset(|)(C )H-CH_(3) underset(Delta)overset("El mechanism")(rarr) (A) Major product (A) is