Home
Class 11
CHEMISTRY
Assertion: The order of stability of car...

Assertion: The order of stability of carbocations is `3^(@) gt 2^(@) gt 1^(@)`
Reason: Carbon atom in carbocation is in `sp^(3)` state of hybridisation.

A

If both assertion and reason are true and reason is the correct explanation of assertion

B

If both assertion and reason are true but reason is not the correct explanation of assertion

C

If assertion is true but reason is false.

D

If both assertion and reason are false.

Text Solution

AI Generated Solution

The correct Answer is:
To solve the assertion and reason question regarding the stability of carbocations, let's break it down step by step. ### Step 1: Understand the Assertion The assertion states that the order of stability of carbocations is: \[ \text{3°} > \text{2°} > \text{1°} \] This means that tertiary carbocations (3°) are more stable than secondary (2°), which in turn are more stable than primary (1°) carbocations. ### Step 2: Understand the Reason The reason provided is that the carbon atom in a carbocation is in the \( sp^3 \) state of hybridization. ### Step 3: Analyze the Stability of Carbocations - **Tertiary Carbocation (3°)**: A tertiary carbocation has three alkyl groups attached to the positively charged carbon. Alkyl groups donate electron density through the +I (inductive) effect and +H (hyperconjugation) effect, stabilizing the positive charge. - **Secondary Carbocation (2°)**: A secondary carbocation has two alkyl groups. It is less stable than a tertiary carbocation but more stable than a primary carbocation due to the same effects, though to a lesser extent. - **Primary Carbocation (1°)**: A primary carbocation has only one alkyl group attached, making it the least stable due to minimal stabilization from the +I and +H effects. ### Step 4: Analyze the Hybridization In a carbocation: - The carbon atom is **sp² hybridized**, not \( sp^3 \). This is because the carbon in a carbocation forms three sigma bonds and has a vacant p-orbital, leading to \( sp^2 \) hybridization (one s and two p orbitals hybridize). ### Step 5: Conclusion - The assertion is **true**: The order of stability of carbocations is indeed \( 3° > 2° > 1° \). - The reason is **false**: The carbon atom in a carbocation is \( sp^2 \) hybridized, not \( sp^3 \). ### Final Answer Thus, the correct conclusion is that the assertion is true, but the reason is false.

To solve the assertion and reason question regarding the stability of carbocations, let's break it down step by step. ### Step 1: Understand the Assertion The assertion states that the order of stability of carbocations is: \[ \text{3°} > \text{2°} > \text{1°} \] This means that tertiary carbocations (3°) are more stable than secondary (2°), which in turn are more stable than primary (1°) carbocations. ### Step 2: Understand the Reason ...
Doubtnut Promotions Banner Mobile Dark
|

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • ORGANIC CHEMISTRY-SOME BASIC PRINCIPLES AND TECHNIQUES

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Tetravalence Of Carbon : Shape Of Organic Compounds|5 Videos
  • ORGANIC CHEMISTRY-SOME BASIC PRINCIPLES AND TECHNIQUES

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Nomenclature Of Organic Compounds|12 Videos
  • ORGANIC CHEMISTRY-SOME BASIC PRINCIPLES AND TECHNIQUES

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Exemplar Problems|12 Videos
  • HYDROGEN

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Assertion And Reason|15 Videos
  • PRACTICE PAPER 1

    NCERT FINGERTIPS ENGLISH|Exercise Practice Paper 1|44 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

The reactivity order of alkyl halide is 3^(@) gt 2^(@) gt 1^(@) in

The reactivity of carbanions follows the order 3^@ gt 2^@ gt 1^@ .

Knowledge Check

  • Assertion: - overset(*) (CH_3 ) acts as an electrophile. Reason :-The carbon atom in overset(*)(CH_3) is in a state of sp^2 hybridisation.

    A
    If both Assertion and Reason are CORRECT and Reason is the CORRECT explanation of the Assertion.
    B
    If both Assertion and Reason are CORRECT but Reason is not the CORRECT explanation of the Assertion.
    C
    If Assertion is CORRECT but Reason is INCORRECT.
    D
    If Assertion is INCORRECT but Reason is CORRECT.
  • Similar Questions

    Explore conceptually related problems

    Which bonds are formed by a carbon atom with sp^(2) -hybridisation ?

    Which bonds are formed by a carbon atom with sp^(2) -hybridisation ?

    The central atom assume sp^(3) hybridisation in:

    All carbon atoms are sp^(2) hybridised in

    The stability of the following carbocations decreases in the order 1) 3) 1)

    Statement-1: Bridge head carbocation is less stable than Bridge head carbanion. and Statement-2: C atom in carbocation is sp^(2) generally hybridized.

    Assertion : The order of basicity of amines in the gaseous phase follows the order : 3^(@) amine gt 2^(@) amine gt 1^(@) amine gt NH_(3) Reason : Amines have an unshared pair of electrons on nitrogen atom due to which they behave as Lewis base .