Home
Class 11
PHYSICS
When a horse pulls a cart, by Newton's I...

When a horse pulls a cart, by Newton's III law the cart also pulls the horse with equal and opposite force, then how does the motion of horse, cart and system takes place?

Text Solution

Verified by Experts

Here the following forces acts along the horizontal,
(1) The force on the cart due to the pull of the horse `F_(CH)`
(2) The force on the horse due to the cart `F_(HC)`
(3) The horizontal force on the cart due to ground f.
(4) The reaction from ground due to the push of horse against the ground `F_(HG)`
The vertical forces on the cart and horse are their weights vertically down while reactions due to contact from ground upward. This all is shown in

So, for the motion of the cart,
`F_(CH) gt f` .....(i)
i.e, the force with which the horse pulls the cart `(F_(CH))` is responsible for the motion of the cart and the cart will move if this force exceeds the static friction (f) between the cart and the ground.
And for the motion of horse
`F_(HG) gt F_(HC)` ....(ii)
i.e, the force which the ground exerts on horse (i.e., `F_(HG)`) is responsible for the motion of the horse and the horse will move if this force exceeds the force with which the cart pulls the horse `(F_(HC))`
And so for the motion of the system [adding Eqns. (i) and (ii)]
`F_(HG)+F_(CH) gt F_(HC)+f`
or `F_(HG) gt f [as F_(CH) = F_(HC)]` ....(iii)
i.e, the force which the ground exert on the horse (due to its push against the ground) is responsible for the motion of the system. Free body diagrams for cart, horse and system are shown in

Note: Same argument is applicable in tug of war. The team that pushes harder against the ground wins. The tension of the rope pulls a team backward. it is the earth's reaction to the push against the ground which supplies the necessary force for pulling.
Promotional Banner

Topper's Solved these Questions

  • FORCE AND NEWTONS LAWS OF MOTION

    GRB PUBLICATION|Exercise Problem|33 Videos
  • FORCE AND NEWTONS LAWS OF MOTION

    GRB PUBLICATION|Exercise Problem for practice|30 Videos
  • BASIC MATHEMATICS

    GRB PUBLICATION|Exercise Problems For Practice|35 Videos
  • FRICTION AND CIRCULAR MOTION

    GRB PUBLICATION|Exercise Comprehension type|11 Videos

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

When a horse pulls a cart, the force that helps the horse to move forward is the force exerted by

When a horse pulls a wagon, the force that causes the horse to move forward is the force

when a horse pulls a cart, the force that helps the horse to move forward is the force exerted by

When a horse pulls a cart, the force which is responsible for the movement of cart is

A horse is urged to pull a wagon the horse refuses to try, citing Newton's third laws as a defense: the pull of the horse on the wagon is equal to but opposite the pull of the wagon on the horse. "If I can never exert a greater force on the wagon than it exerts on me, how can I ever start the wagon moving ?" Asks the horse. How would you reply ?

According to Newton's third law each team pulls the opposite team with equal force in a tug of war. Why then one team wins aned the other loses?